HoldIt vs GymMate vs HolyH2O: Which Magnetic Gym Bag Is Actually Worth Buying?

The magnetic gym bag category is small but growing fast in Australia. If you have done any research, you have probably come across three names: HoldIt, GymMate, and HolyH2O. This comparison covers what each bag actually offers, what the reviews say, and which one is worth buying for Australian gym-goers in 2026.

Note: This article is written by the HoldIt team. We have done our best to represent competitors fairly, but you should factor that in when reading the comparison.

The Comparison at a Glance

HoldIt

HoldIt is the only magnetic gym bag brand here with a significant Australian customer base and local fulfilment. It ships from Sydney within 48 hours, which matters if you have been burned by long international shipping times on cheaper alternatives.

The magnet shielding is the key technical differentiator. HoldIt explicitly tests and guarantees that the magnetic base will not damage your phone, cards, or electronics. That is not a claim GymMate or HolyH2O make clearly on their product pages. If you want the technical breakdown, read our article on how magnetic gym bags work.

With 895+ verified reviews averaging 4.5/5, HoldIt has the strongest review base of any magnetic gym bag available in Australia. The most frequently mentioned positives are clean setup, phone safety, and the bag staying in place during sessions.

GymMate

GymMate ships internationally, including to Australia. It is generally priced slightly lower than HoldIt and has a similar form factor. The main limitations for Australian buyers are international shipping times, limited Australian reviews, and no explicit magnet shielding guarantee.

HolyH2O

HolyH2O leans harder into water bottle integration. It is priced at the lower end of the category and has more limited capacity than HoldIt and GymMate. The magnet strength is lower, which limits the load it can carry. For Australian buyers, the same international shipping drawbacks apply.

The Verdict

For Australian gym-goers, HoldIt is the clear choice. Local fulfilment, explicit magnet shielding, the strongest review base in the category, and a 30-day no-worries guarantee make it the lowest-risk option at a price point that remains competitive once you factor in shipping.

If you are outside Australia or price is your only filter, GymMate is the strongest alternative. HolyH2O is worth considering only if a magnetic water bottle holder is your main use case.

In a category this small, details like local fulfilment, verified reviews, and phone safety matter more than shaving a few dollars off the price.